
I think this entire opening gave me hives, from the use of “alleged” and “altercation” to the somehow insanely wrong photo caption under this dude’s headshot.
THE LEAD: Just because you tell the readers something happened, it doesn’t mean you actually informed them.
Check out the following leads from a variety of media outlets after Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers fired UW Regent Timothy Nixon:
A University of Wisconsin System regent has been removed from the board.
There are at least a half dozen more of these stories, all with essentially the same lead about an “incident” or an “altercation” that occurred late last week. Every story follows the same basic pattern:
- Guy got fired due to “altercation” lead.
- Quote from Evers press release.
- Background on this guy.
- Quote from regents backing Evers.
- Closing explaining Evers will let incoming Gov. David Crowley fill the seat.
What don’t we know? Almost everything important.
WHY SOURCE DEVELOPMENT MATTERS: Some of the best reporters I’ve ever met had something that mediocre folks like me didn’t: Sources. The reason why so many of them were able to do amazing journalism was because they knew people, formed relationships with those people and found a way to tap into those relationships for the benefit of the readers.
It’s why people like Pat Simms and George Hesselberg were always leaps and bounds ahead of every other media outlet in Madison as well as everyone else in the newsroom, in most cases. They had people who they could ask, “OK, what the hell happened?” and get full and honest answers. They also were capable of poking reticent sources to give up the goods.
They worked the phones, met with people and generally got to know who would tell them what, under which circumstances and how hard it would be to crack that nut. They understood that the first answer wasn’t always the best or most complete answer and that taking whatever came to them on a press release at face value flew in the face of doing their job right.
That’s what reporting gets you: The full and complete story. What else does it get you? The trust and respect of those consuming your content as well as that of your peers.
THE PROBLEM WITH SOFT LANGUAGE AND SOFT REPORTING: The term “altercation” could mean almost anything. Questions I have involve the following:
- Who else was involved? Dare I say you don’t have an altercation with yourself, unless you’re Jim Carrey in “Liar Liar.” That makes a huge difference in what’s going on here, based on things like power imbalance, political disagreements or generally creating fear in another person.
- Was this verbal or physical? If this guy is out there throwing punches, that’s one thing. If he’s just loud, hell, that’s a guy down the hall from my office on a daily basis. It also brings in the question of if criminal charges could be filed at some point, as yelling isn’t always a crime, but punching someone is.
- If it were verbal, did it involve any “third-rail topics?” We’ve talked about these things before, but basically if you end up touching on certain topics, you’re getting canned no matter what the context.
- Has he done something like this before? In most cases, when you fire someone, it’s either based on a long history of bad behavior, or a single social media post that goes viral for all the wrong reasons.
I could add about a half dozen more, but the point is that somebody in ONE of these media outlets needed to ask at least SOME questions related to these topics. Even if people on the other end won’t answer them in a direct way, you can do some process-of-elimination reporting based on what they won’t tell you.
Spokesperson Bill Smith would not say if the situation was physical or verbal.
Spokesperson Jane Jones would not say if Nixon had previous “altercations” of this kind.
Spokesperson Jacob Williams would not say who else was involved in the situation.
At the very least, you’re getting SOMEWHERE in putting information into the universe. However, when you don’t engage in some form of reporting, you’re left with soft language, meaning people can let their minds run free as to what could have happened.
THE “BOY NAMED SUE” AXIOM: I would often push sources to tell me at least some of what they could tell me with the idea that not telling me would make things far worse for them. If they told me it was an “altercation” and someone got fired, I’d argue with them that people are going to assume the person who got fired either got really racist or punched someone or threatened to kill someone or… God alone knows! Wouldn’t you rather just tell me a little something, even off the record, to make sure that things don’t go off the rails?
In teaching students how this works, I use what I call the “Boy Named Sue” Axiom. The famous Johnny Cash song, written by Shel Silverstein of all people, tells the tale of “Sue” a boy whose father named him such before he abandoned the family. Sue grows up having this terrible name, leading to fights and a final promise to kill his father if he ever finds him. Once he finds his father, the dad explains that he gave him that name to make him strong because he wouldn’t have a father in his life.
In the famous reveal, the father notes :
But you ought to thank me, before I dieFor the gravel in ya gut and the spit in ya eye‘Cause I’m the (BLEEEP) that named you Sue.
In never knowing what was behind that bleep, people had flights of fancy regarding what it could be. Mother****er was a pretty common claim, given both the censor-ability and the literal meaning there, as was “c*******er” as that’s a pretty vile term. A few other choice words came up among those of us who were fans and wondering what it was.
Turned out it was “son of a bitch,” something so relatively tame that I don’t think my editors at Sage would have a conniption if I just let that go as is.
The point was that by hiding something, the more likely it was people would OVERESTIMATE the severity of the problem. It’s like if a kid tried opening one of my desk drawers and I screamed, “NO! NOT THAT ONE! NEVER THAT ONE!” as I slammed my body up against it. It might just be my mediocre sophomore year breakup poetry, but I bet the kid thinks there’s a severed head in there.
The overall point is that when a press release tries to soft-pedal a story with vague language and limited information, the best journalists make sure to go above and beyond what’s on the paper for the good of the readers, but also for the good of those involved.













