The Junk Drawer: “What Were They THINKING?” Edition

How many rolls of tape does one man need? At least this many…

Welcome to this edition of the junk drawer. As we have outlined in previous junk drawer posts, this is a random collection of stuff that is important but didn’t fit anywhere else, much like that drawer in the kitchen of most of our homes.

This is a good time to catch up with a few things that either fell through the cracks or demand an update.

Let’s take a spin:

BETTER LATE THAN NEVER… SORT OF: 

Earlier this week, I did some grousing that our local media outlets didn’t explain what former UW Regent Timothy Nixon did to merit his firing. The State Journal’s follow-up story was… well… slightly less uninformative:

Nixon attempted to bypass a required security screening in the hallway outside of a public forum for the university’s chancellor search on Friday at the Memorial Union, campus police spokesperson Marc Lovicott said.

UW police officers working at the event directed Nixon to leave the event, and he complied. After interviews with witnesses and an investigation, police issued Nixon citations for violating UW codes against disorderly conduct and assaultive behavior, Lovicott said.

Pull the damned police report and let’s get some details. I want to know who said what about whose mama…

Speaking of not being all that informative…

 

LOOK, YOU KNOW EVERYTHING WE KNOW:

A former student sent me this printed page from a local college paper:

I guess we all know all we’re gonna know…

Speaking of lack of clarity…

 

IF YOU CAN DIAGRAM THIS HEADLINE, YOU WIN A PRIZE:

Some stories are exceptionally complicated, thus making headline writing a bit of a challenge:

Earlier this month, a Wisconsin kid, who was attending college at Ole Miss, was one of two people who made “monkey noises” in front of an apartment that is rented by multiple African American students.

The incident was caught on the door cam and put on social media, leading to the student dropping out and returning home to Wisconsin, where her family owns and operates a local car dealership. That car dealership had previous legal issues related to racism, unrelated to the current racism issue, for which the former student has apologized.

How in the world can you cover all that in one chunk of “big type?” Not like this:

 

I have no idea how many ways this can be read, but the first three I tried were wrong…

Speaking of things that are just flat-out wrong…

 

GIMME A “C!” GIMME A “U!” GIMME AN “N…” WAIT…

When I saw this online, I immediately thought it was a spoof shirt:

Screenshot

Turns out that a) it’s real and b) it’s part of Colorado’s student lore… Somebody at SOME POINT must have stopped and said, “Wait… You think this is a good idea?”

I know that there are times where things get named for initials or idea. For example, the University of South Carolina’s radio station is WUSC. However the University of North Texas was forward-thinking enough to say, “Our prefix on the radio on this side of the Mississippi is “K” so maybe we go with KNTU instead of…”

I thought it was just me who saw that went, “Oh, hell no…” but immediately after sharing it, I got a half dozen, “I swear that said…” responses. Then again, I’m not from Colorado or part of the C-UNIT (ED NOTE: Triple-check that spelling…) so I don’t understand the situation.

And finally, speaking of other things I don’t understand…

 

WHAT IS THE UNIQUE SELLING PROPOSITION IN THIS PARTICULAR AD? 

I was scrolling Facebook marketplace looking for a vintage truck that might make for a good winter restoration project when I came upon this ad:

Trust me when I say I read the whole ad and I remained flummoxed. Are we trying to sexy this up with a “booth babe,” even though those ads are essentially verboten these days? Are we trying to say, “Look how sturdy this is!” as part of the sales pitch? Are we trying to start a “bikinis-with-sneakers” fashion trend?

Wonder if it ever sold…

Have a great week.

Vince (a.k.a. The Doctor of Paper)

Around the Bases of Life with My Dad and the Milwaukee Brewers

I’m sitting alone on my couch as I write this, witnessing something I’d never thought I’d see in my lifetime: A World Series Championship for the Milwaukee Brewers.

Somewhere in the late innings of the 4-1 clincher, I texted my mom:

“How is Dad doing?

Her response: “Tense…”

If you have been a Milwaukee Brewers fan as long as he has been, that totally makes sense. You never want to even HOPE that it MIGHT be our turn because that hope is so fragile that it seems like the universe is just taunting us, daring us to hope, just to crush that hope.

Hope has not been the friend of Brewers fans since 1982, the last time the team went to the World Series. We’ve consistently endured last-place finishes, horrible managerial choices, bad drafts and mediocre teams. The other constant over the past 44 years has been the trove of memories the Brewers have provided to Dad and me.

 

An early photo of Dad and me outside our old house on Armor Avenue. Just a brief reminder that the 1970s were not good to anyone who wore clothes.

I was 8 years old in 1982 when Dad took me to my first baseball game. Had he known it was Bat Day in the middle of a pennant race, he might have thought twice about going that day.

We climbed into the upper deck of old County Stadium and the first thing I noticed was the giant barrel and mug in the outfield. Dad explained that when a Brewer hit a homer, a guy would slide down from the barrel into the mug and release balloons, but I shouldn’t get my hopes up, as homers were rare.

The Brewers hit four that day.

Hitting homers had become the trademark of that team. It was known as Harvey’s Wallbangers, a play on the name of manager Harvey Kuenn and the popular 1970s drink. All summer and into fall, we followed the Brewers’ charge to the top of the standings, listening to announcer Bob Uecker on the radio or catching the local broadcast on Channel 18.

A Harvey Wallbanger: 1.5 oz vodka, 4 oz OJ, 1/2 oz Galliano. Mix the OJ and vodka, then float the Galliano on top. You’re welcome.

We made it all the way to the World Series that year, only to lose in seven games. Mom sent me to bed early in Game 7, but I snuck out of my upstairs bedroom and crouched silently at the top of the steps, straining to hear the TV in the living room. When the game finally ended with a Gorman Thomas strike out, I slunk back to bed and I cried.

Still, there was always next year. There had to be. We had five future hall of famers on that team. Heck, if Rollie Fingers doesn’t get hurt toward the end of the season, we probably would have won it all. Harvey Kuenn was coming back as manager. We had more experience.

Next year, we all thought. Wait until next year.

That year, 1983, the Brewers finished a respectable 87-75, but management fired Kuenn. A year later, the team finished 36.5 games out of first. With a few notable teases, it didn’t much better than that for quite some time.

As far as Dad and I were concerned, it wasn’t bad at all. He managed to get in with some guys who shared a season ticket package consisting of four front-row seats along the third-base line. We got something like a dozen games a year and each one was a thrill.

No matter what game we got that first season, it seemed like Bill Wegman was always pitching, which made sense as he started 32 games that year, finishing with a 5-12 record.

I also caught my first ball that year, tossed to me by Cleveland pitcher Jamie Easterly.

“Caught” might be a bit of an overstatement, as he tossed it to me and I dropped it. The ball rolled down the tarp in front of our seats and out onto the warning track. Easterly took pity on me, jogging back to pick it up and put it in my hand.

“Don’t drop it this time, kid,” he said as he trotted out to the bullpen.

That day, a Cleveland baseball fan was born. Another tragic tale of wasted youth…

It wasn’t the only ball we’d get in those seats, with one of the more memorable ones coming off the bat of slugger Rob Deer.

In the ninth inning of a losing effort, Deer fouled a ball down the third-base line. It went right into our seats, through my dad’s hands and into the skull of my friend Sean’s dad. County Stadium personnel rushed us to the infirmary, where they made sure he was OK. When they finally released us, the game was over, the stadium was empty and we were locked inside.

As we tried to figure out how to get back to the car, we spotted pitcher Teddy Higuera, giving autographs to a couple kids. Sean and I went over and he signed our scorecards. As that was happening, more players kept coming our way, so we kept getting autographs. At that point, we figured we’d wait for Deer and see if he could sign the ball he’d hit.

Eventually, a security guard unlocked a gate and chased us out, but we caught up with Deer in the parking lot, who obliged us. Sean’s dad put a bandaid on the signed ball as a joke and displayed it proudly on his mantle.

Of all the autographs on this, I treasure Gorman Thomas the most. After he signed for me, Dad asked, “Who was that homeless looking janitor you were talking to?”

Over the years, players often stopped by our seats during batting practice for an autograph or to toss us a ball. Boston Red Sox first baseman Bill Buckner even put his glove down in front of me as stopped to tie his shoe.

“Hey, Bill,” Dad called out to him. “How about an autograph for the kid?”

Buckner didn’t even look up. “I don’t do that stuff.” He then walked away.

(Later that year, this happened to Buckner. I will not claim causation, merely correlation.)

Eventually, we stopped being part of that ticket package, as I got older and we had more commitments. Still, Dad would get us tickets to a game or two, here or there. When we weren’t at the stadium, he’d have the ballgame on the radio while he was working in the garage or doing some yard work.

When I moved back home after 10 years out of state, we found ourselves going to games again. One of my favorite moments was when the whole family went to a game together. Dad and Zoe sat next to each other as he explained how certain parts of the game worked as she munched on a soft pretzel.

That year, the Brewers made a run toward the playoffs, clinching the wildcard berth on the last day of the season. The minute the Marlins beat the Mets to seal the deal, my phone rang. It was Dad.

“Get some tickets. We’re going to a playoff game.”

The Brewers lost that series 3-1 to the Phillies, but we saw the one game they won.

That started the halcyon days of fandom for us, as each year we seemed to make one more step toward the Promised Land. The Wild Card, the NLDS, the NLCS… Dad and I caught a game each of those steps, managing to see them win a game in each series.

The thing I remember most about those games wasn’t the hitting or pitching or score, but how wonderful it was to be there with Dad and how much he loved those experiences. In a textbook definition of irony, he was genuinely happy to be in a crowded place, filled with lines, that charged more for a single beer than he’d pay for a 12 pack. Being in those moments with him reminded me why I wanted to move home in the first place.

Over the past few years, we kept saying the same thing to each other, “Can you imagine what a World Series game would be like? If the Brewers make it, we’re going.”

For the past eight years, they came so tantalizingly close… Each year, we waited… waited until next year…

When “next year” finally became this year, I found myself desperately pounding the keyboard in my office, trying to get tickets to one of the games in Milwaukee. Amid the chaos, I managed to land a pair that cost more than my first car, which naturally freaked me out, so I called Mom. Turns out, she was in church that weekday morning, praying that we’d get tickets.

“It’s fine,” she said. “We’ve got it covered. Whatever it takes. You guys need to go.”

So, last week, I drove down to Milwaukee on Friday to catch Game 1. We paid $20 to park in a driveway about a mile from the stadium, the money apparently going to the Lego fund of the kids whose parents lived there.

After we sat down in  our seats, oddly enough located along the third-base line near the tarp, Dad turned to me and said, “This is worth every nickel.” It was still three hours before the first pitch.

As the teams took the field, Dad turned to me and said, “This is amazing. I’m just shaking.”

To explain the next three hours takes more than I can put into words. The whole night was a blur. I think I bought a couple giant beers and and high-fived at least a dozen strangers. Dad never stopped smiling.

After the game was over and we were back at home somewhere around midnight, neither of us could even think about sleeping. We just kept talking about the game over and over and over.

“This was one of the greatest moments of my life,” Dad said.

“Me too,” I replied. “Thanks, Dad. Thanks for everything.”

 

 

 

A Year After He Was Fired For Not Censoring The Indiana Daily Student, Jim Rodenbush Reflects On Life, Student Media And His New Gig

Jim Rodenbush was a student media adviser, First-Amendment advocate and champion for experiential learning in journalism at Indiana University until he was fired one year ago. In discussing the stupidity of his firing, he was open about the way in which university officials were disingenuous in their dealings with him and how his unwillingness to forsake the student journalists led to his dismissal.

He also talked a lot about how what was the start of the worst year of his life ended up reminding him of why he fought in the first place. All the people he knew over the years, and many he’d never known, popped out of the woodwork to offer help and support, something that really meant something to him.

Jim is no longer a student media adviser, but he is still actively involved in shaping student journalists in his new gig at Western Kentucky. He remains a First-Amendment advocate and champion for all the good things that great educators do for their students.

To encapsulate this crazy year is beyond my ability, but fortunately, Jim took to LinkedIn to give his friends and colleagues a recap. It’s published below with permission from Jim:


 

One year ago today, I was fired from Indiana University.

A lot can happen in one year. You would think being fired would be a defining event. Turns out, it wasn’t even close.

One week later, my dad died. Three months after that, my sister died. I moved twice. I started over in a new place, with a new job and a new community.

Along the way, I experienced pretty much every emotion you could imagine. When you feel like you’ve been kicked to the curb by your employer, it’s not a happy time. You go through it all — sadness, anger, defiance. Then, a period of really weird quiet. There were days when I considered if my career was over. Days when I wondered whether I had somehow ruined my life. Days when I wasn’t sure what would come next. When you’re unemployed for months, you have time to sit with all of those questions.

When looking back over the past year, it’s easy to first think about the person who went through everything with me.

My wife Jackie received a crash course in the First Amendment that she never asked for. She lived through every one of my emotions, every uncertainty, every move, every conversation about whether I had somehow blown up our lives. She watched me struggle with not knowing what came next while dealing with her own upheaval.

Through it all, she was strong, patient and graceful. She was willing to go through this with me, even though none of it was something she had chosen. I don’t know how you adequately thank someone for that. I’ll spend the rest of our lives figuring it out.

So many other people showed up too. Students, former colleagues, friends, journalism organizations, people I hadn’t heard from in years and people I barely knew. Then there was Bowling Green. I found a welcoming home at Western Kentucky University. The Hilltoppers have made starting over feel less like starting over. I’m grateful for that in ways I can’t fully explain just yet.

In the end, it’s weird. One of the greatest gifts of the past year may have been getting fired. Not because getting fired was good. It wasn’t. It was bad in all the possible ways. But because that moment will forever show people who I am.

When I had a choice between protecting my job and protecting what I believed student journalists deserved, I made my choice. A year later, I know that choice cost me something. I also know what it gave me, and that’s a much better understanding of who I am when things get hard.

So today isn’t really an anniversary of getting fired. It’s an anniversary of looking back at a year I never would have chosen and realizing that, somehow, there is a lot of good in life on the other side of it.

Oh, and, if there is ever such a thing as a cool souvenir from an awful moment in your life, this screen grab of an email from Mark Cuban to an IDS reporter is it. For Mark, I can be Jim Rosebush.

A Question For Media Pros: Is “Deadline” Not A Thing Anymore?

(I was never as rebellious as Spicoli, but have I become Mr. Hand?)

My mom had a friend she worked with on various projects over the years who was always late, usually by a half hour or more. This irritated my mother to no end, as she’s a “I need to be 10 minutes early” person and her friend had no sense of why being late was such a bother.

At one point, the friend asked, “What’s the big deal? Why are you so upset about me being late?” My mom’s answer was a great one:

“When you are late, you are telling me that you value your time more than mine,” Mom said. “If you value our time equally, then you’ll be here on time. In making our plans, you’ve asked me to set aside time for you and this plan you value, time I could otherwise be doing something else that matters to me. Then, when you don’t show up on time, you tell me that the plan, the time and my efforts really don’t matter to you.”

I use this story to try to help students understand why it’s important to show up early, or at least on time, for interviews and meetings with sources. It would really work great, if half the classes I’m teaching these days weren’t too late in showing up to hear it.

The point of this post isn’t to complain about “kids these days” or generally just shout at a cloud, but to really ask a serious question of media practitioners out there:

“Do deadlines matter anymore in our field?”

The goal of every class I teach is to prepare students for what is coming at them when they take a job in the field. That means tighter writing, accuracy of content, fact checking and especially deadlines. In regard to that last one, I try to set fair and yet firm deadlines for their work to be done, which more and more students are having a harder and harder time of making.

Case in point, the intro writing class got a “quotes” assignment on Wednesday. The goal to interview anyone (I literally did not care whom they interviewed, so long as it wasn’t a pet. I let a kid do it once and there were only so many “Meow” quotes I could handle.) and then build about a page-long story based on that interview, relying on the paraphrase-quote pairings we discussed.

I used to set deadlines at noon, but students said that was “confusing” because the LLM system listed it as “12:00 PM” which they took to mean at night. (I’m amazed, but not surprised…) This time, I listed it at “11:30 AM” as I’m assuming in most parts of the country, “AM” means “morning” (although AP style would call it a.m.).

Out of 40 students, 20 made the deadline. Another eight emailed me after the drop box locked at 7 p.m. and they were befuddled by their inability to turn something in.

The syllabus notes that no late assignments will be tolerated, but I decided to take the late ones from the kids who at least emailed. Still, that’s 28/40, a phenomenal team winning percentage in the MLB, about 20 points higher than Shaq’s free-throw percentage in the NBA and ridiculous for making a deadline in my mind.

Deadline used to be the driver of everything we did in media. I still remember once  was working night desk when the story about a kid “clinging to life” became a story of “a kid died.” After I got off the phone with the hospital, my editor came over to my desk, looked at my notes and said, “Oh shit… You have to rewrite Brenda’s story. You have four minutes.”

I thought it was metaphor or hyperbole, but as I was cramming chips into my mouth and scrolling slowly through the story, he returned.

“What the hell are you doing?” he asked. “You have 3 minutes and 30 seconds. The presses are heating up!”

One whirling dervish later, the story was functionally beaten into shape, but I never forgot that four minutes meant four damned minutes.

Even now, deadlines matter to me. I have a giant post-it on the wall for every book I do, reminding me of what has been sent and what needs to go. I was never more embarrassed than the time I missed a deadline because of a misunderstanding between me and my new editor.

I owed four chapters per deadline period, the first of which she said was going to be September. In all my previous interactions with Sage, I got a specific date or just had it due by the end of the month. Right around Labor Day, I got a “Hey, just checking in to see how this is going” email, to which I said things were find and I was about halfway done.

A couple days later, I got another, “Just seeing how you are doing in getting the chapters done” email. Perplexed again, I responded that I was fine, so relax and let me work.

That next week, I got the, “You are past deadline, so we’re kind of concerned we haven’t seen anything yet,” email, which put me on my heels. I tore through all my notes and then immediately called the editor:

Me: My deadline is September. It’s still September. I should have like 17 days left before I’m “late” for anything.

Her: It was due Sept. 1. That’s what I told you.

Me: Um, no, I’ve got everything here and you said, “September” so why would I assume I didn’t have September to work on it.

Her: I always work off the first of any month. That’s always been Sage’s policy.

I was mortified and negotiated another week from her, only to turn the last of the stuff around in four days. When I sent the email with the chapters and an apology for being about 16 days late, she sent me back a reassuring email with this note:

“Don’t worry. Some authors are more than two years past their deadlines…”

How in the hell is that possible, I wondered, only to find out from another friend at Sage that some folks are more than half a decade behind in their deadline pursuit.

Five years?

That’s the gap between birth and kindergarten, the amount of time a four-year degree takes to complete or the length of the worst NFL contract of all time. And the people blowing off a book deadline are likely the same people who are likely to refuse to accept late work from students…

Getting back to the original point, I know that a lot of things change over time in the field in which I teach. We no longer teach “counting beats” to measure headlines or require a pica pole in design classes. We also don’t teach people how to “cut tape” for broadcast, whether that was physically razor-blading something or cutting from Hi-8 tape to Hi-8 tape.

Is deadline one of those things now where being punctual doesn’t matter as much, because we don’t have to worry about press costs? (I imagine television news still has some significant issues if people are blowing stuff off, but I could be wrong.)

Is holding firm on a deadline important to teach a valuable lesson or is it like reminding students to set their clocks back for daylight saving time, a quaint reminder of a generation gap that emphasizes something no longer necessary?

Tell me what you think in general, not accounting for real excuses like last-minute surgery, car accidents or family crises. Those I already have carve outs for. I’m talking about the general and perpetual land of “Oh… Yeah… Can I, like, still turn that in?” situations, where students view deadlines as being as flexible as Silly Putty.

Pros (and profs if you’re interested in chiming in), the phone lines are open and your call is very important to us… Operators are standing by, so tell me what you think. 

 

The Dartmouth Provost Used AI To Write His Opinion Pieces. When The Student Newspaper Called Him Out, He Replied With An AI-Written Statement (A Throwback Post)

The topper of the amazing story done by The Dartmouth on the AI use of their provost.

 

THE LEAD: The next time your professor tells you, “If you just let AI do all your writing for you, you’ll never be able to get a job,” you can now respond with, “Well, I could be the provost of Dartmouth…”

An investigation by The Dartmouth of academic articles and opinion pieces published by Provost Santiago Schnell in 2026 found a median “AI-written” text percentage of 96% using artificial intelligence detector Pangram.

Pangram — which was found to have a “near-zero error rate” by an October 2025 University of Chicago audit — uses a large language model neural network which is trained to recognize differences between separate datasets of human-written documents and AI-generated content, according to the company’s website.

The student journalists at Dartmouth University did an amazingly strong deep dive into this topic, relying on both the most accurate AI-detection program available and some strong reporting beyond that. This wasn’t a quick-hit piece on one thing Schnell wrote, but rather a comprehensive look at his work before and after AI chatbots became widely available.

In addition, they sought and received a comment from Schnell about their findings, but didn’t just give him a pass. Instead, they took each of his claims (it was for grammar only… AI picks on people who have ESL concerns… etc.) and debunked each one of them.

And as if that weren’t enough to make the point, they also found this:

In an email statement to The Dartmouth on Sept. 18, Schnell wrote that he uses artificial intelligence for “language refinement, copyediting, improving clarity and organization and making writing processes more efficient,” but “review[s] the final text and take[s] responsibility for its content.”

“I develop ideas and arguments, conduct the research, evaluate the evidence and sources, determine the structure, prepare drafts and decide what appears in the final text,” Schnell wrote. “I regard these technologies as assistive tools. They do not identify the problem, design the research project, guarantee the validity of research results, interpretations, citations, conclusions or substitute for my research, intellectual judgment or authorship.”

Schnell’s Sept. 18 email statement to The Dartmouth was itself “100% AI-written,” according to a Pangram test.

I imagine next time, the Dartmouth students will want to do a sit down interview with this guy, just to see if he’s capable of doing so…

Given this kind of stuff is now everywhere, even places we generally would expect to be a little more honest, here’s a throwback post that talks about how best to avoid AI fake-outs and keep yourself out of trouble.


 

How AI “expert sources” have duped journalists and four tips on how to avoid being the next victim

 

Meet Elizabeth Hubbell, a 25-year-old skin-care expert who is willing to be a great source for your next story on anything makeup or skin-care related. She’s actually completely fabricated. Her picture came from an AI generation site and her name is a combination of my car (Betsy) and a baseball player whose card I had laying around (Carl Hubbell). Careful. It’s dangerous out there…

When it comes to doing interviews, I always tell students they need to do them in person.  In response, they often look at me like I’m asking them to use a teletype machine or some semaphore flags. It’s easier, faster and more convenient for both parties if they can do a text, a chat or an email interview, the students say.

I argue that the face-to-face interview allows for a deeper connection for profile and feature pieces. This approach also can prevent sources in news stories from weaseling out of answers they could otherwise work through via several drafts of an email. Plus, if I spend some time in the source’s environment, I can probably find a personal effect that could give us something to talk about, like a family photo, a kid’s drawing or a sports item. At the very least, it’ll help with scene setting.

Apparently, there’s another good reason for my approach these days: Your easy-to-access, extremely helpful, expert source might be AI:

Since the launch of ChatGPT in 2022, anyone can generate comment, on any subject, in an instant.

It is a technology that appears to have fuelled a rise in expert commentators who have appeared widely in national newspapers but who are either not real, not what they seem to be or at the very least have CVs which do not justify their wide exposure in major newsbrands.

The rise in dubious commentators has been fuelled by companies that charge the PR industry in order to share quotes via email with journalists who have submitted requests for comment.

Journalist Rob Waugh found that in a number of cases, digital outlets were mass-generating content from these supposed experts, giving everyone from news journalists to PR practitioners the exact the quote or information they needed on a wide array of topics. However, when challenged to engage more deeply regarding who they are or what they have done in life, the “sources” suddenly had difficulty:

She has been quoted in Fortune talking about “loud budgeting” and by Business.com talking about the best countries in which to obtain a business education (both sites are based in the US).

A profile on Academized describes her as a “biochemist and science educator”. The same byline picture also crops up on a publisher called Leaddev, for someone called Sara Sparrow. Rebecca Leigh has written for DrBicuspid.com about how to write a business plan for your dental practice where she is described as a writer for Management Essay and Lija Help (two online writing services).

When challenged via email to do something that would be difficult to do with AI image-generating software (send an image of herself with her hand in front of her face) or prove that she was an environment expert, Rebecca stopped communicating.

One AI source, “Barbara Santini,” was particularly prolific in the volume and array of topics she could cover for journalists. Waugh found this roster of publications that had included Santini quotes:

She has been quoted in The Guardian talking about the benefits of walking (paid content), in Newsweek talking about white lies, Marie Claire talking about the meaning of money, the Daily Mirror talking about the benefits of sleeping with your dog, in The Sun talking about sexual positions, Pop Sugar talking about astrology, and Mail Online talking about how often to change your pillow.

Santini was recently quoted in a BBC article examining the lifelike responses of AI to Rorschach tests used by some psychologists saying: “If an AI’s response resembles a human’s, it’s not because it sees the same thing but it’s because its training data mirrors our collective visual culture.”

Despite her ability to be all knowing and wise, Santini apparently couldn’t receive phone calls, a relatively easy giveaway that the “person” on the other end is AI. Waugh also found other examples of journalists who were getting taken for a ride by an AI source, including one case where the non-human pitched a sob story about breast cancer survival:

“Seeing my scarred chest in the mirror was a constant reminder of what I had lost,” Kimberly Shaw, 30, told me in an emotional email.

She had contacted me through Help a Reporter Out, a service used by journalists to find sources. I cover skincare and had been using the site to find people for a story about concealing acne scars with tattoos.

<SNIP>

Shaw’s experience may not have been relevant to my acne story, but it tapped into the same feelings of empowerment and control I wanted to explore. Thinking she could inspire a powerful new piece, I emailed her back.

But after days of back-and-forth conversations, something in Shaw’s emails began to feel a little off. After idly wondering to my boyfriend whether she could be a fake, he suggested that I run the emails through a text checker for artificial intelligence.

The result was unequivocal: Shaw’s emails had been machine-generated. I’d been interviewing an AI the entire time.

As a result of Waugh’s story, a number of these information clearinghouses have tried to cull their ranks of AI “experts” while the deceived publications have retooled or removed the stories with fake people in them. Although the founder of one of these “expert mills” blamed much of the situation on “lazy journalists,” he kind of gave up the game a bit when it came to explaining why these platforms don’t prevent the frauds from gaining access in the first place:

Darryl Willcox, who founded ResponseSource in 1997 and sold it in 2018, says that the simplicity and speed of platforms like ResponseSource is key to their appeal and that attempts to add authentication risk slowing down the system.

Willcox said: “The other factor which complicates things a little bit is that these platforms are quite an open system. Once a journalist makes a request they can be forwarded around organisations, and sometimes between them, and often PR agencies are acting for multiple parties, and they will be forwarded onto their many clients.”

In other words, “If we slowed down to make sure things were accurate, we wouldn’t be as appealing as we want to be.” Eeesh.

So what can you to to avoid quoting a fake person? The overarching theme is basically, “Don’t be a lazy journalist,” but here are a few more specific tips:

TRUST, BUT VERIFY: The old Russian proverb really comes into play here and for good reason. I often say that paranoia is my best friend and has kept me out of a ton of problems. To that larger point, not only did I click on every link I could find in Waugh’s story, I also Googled the hell out of Waugh himself. Why? I imagined that it would be the most epic “Punk’d” moment on Earth if the media world was flocking to this story about AI screwing with journalists, only to find out that Rob Waugh was also an AI fake. I found LinkedIn, X, Bluesky, media staff pages and at least a dozen photos. I wouldn’t bet the house on the fact he’s real, but I’d probably bet the lawn tractor.

This can be harder in situations like the one involving the cancer scammer, as regular people tend not to have as big of a social media presence or digital footprint. That said, even regular people under the age of retirement should have left a few breadcrumbs out there for you to find.

KICK THE TIRES: If you can’t find the person clearly through a digital search, feel free to play a little game of 20 Questions to see if you can get some things ironed out. Experts who have kicked the tires on a few bots can offer you specific ways to ask questions that will tend to ferret out fakers. The author in the cancer-scam story revealed that asking for specific photos based on prior conversations can be helpful as well.

I learned about this kind of thing in trying to defeat scams when it came to buying sports memorabilia. When unknown sellers offered either exactly what I wanted when I couldn’t find it anywhere else or provided me with a ridiculously low price for something I knew should cost more, the pros who had been around the block a few times suggested I ask the seller to “coin the image.”

What this meant was that I wanted the person to take a picture of the item with a coin (usually asking for either heads or tails, or maybe even a specific coin) so I could tell they had the item and weren’t messing with me. Turned out, that advice helped me dodge a bullet or two. As weird as it might seem, asking someone to take a picture with their left hand raised or holding a quarter with “heads” showing might help you avoid a problem.

MEET IN PERSON: Again, this is the most obvious one to suggest. If you meet a person, in person, it’s a pretty safe bet that you can consider them real. The rest of the stuff (Are they the expert they claim to be? Did they really do what they say they did? Do they actually have cancer?) remains a risk without substantial additional reporting, but at least you’ll know they exist.

If that can’t happen for legitimate reasons (the person lives too far away etc.), look for other ways to get some human connection with the source. That could be a Zoom/Teams/Whatever video chat or an actual phone call at an actual phone number. In the cases where the frauds proliferated, it was pretty clear that the only connection between the source and the journalist was through a keyboard. That’s especially dangerous when you don’t have a prior relationship with a source.

WHEN IN DOUBT, DO WITHOUT: At the end of the day, there is no journalistic rule that says you have to use a source, a quote or a “fact” just because you have it. If you don’t feel comfortable with how a source is providing you with information or you aren’t 100% sure this person is a person, it’s better to leave that source out of your story than it is to run the risk of getting bamboozled.

If you say, “Well, the whole story will fall apart without this one source and I can’t get anyone else to provide me with this information,” maybe that’s more revealing than anything else we’ve said here.

For Stanford, DEI stands for “Don’t Edit It”: University uses AI to add a Black student to its Dining Advertising

(The Stanford Review at Stanford University showcased the original photo and the “diversified” image the school used in its advertising.)

 

THE LEAD: If at first you can’t make your campus look diverse, let AI do it for you:

Stanford Residential & Dining Enterprises recently used AI to change the races of the students it included in its advertisements. AI was also used to noticeably slim down and alter students’ faces.

On his journey to campus, Stanford student Billy Ramirez ’27 was sent an image he recalled a Stanford photographer taking. Upon closer examination, he noticed that he had been removed from the photo and replaced by a AI-generated black woman.

On top of the swap out of Ramirez, the AI apparently decided the Asian lady could stand to lose a few pounds and that the white kid needed a better haircut.

And we wonder where young people get their issues…

 

DOCTOR OF PAPER FLASHBACK: Not to get too “old man shouting at cloud” about this, but back in the day at the University of Wisconsin Madison, administrators didn’t need AI to improve diversity.

They used Photoshop:

MADISON, Wis., Sept. 24 (AP) — The University of Wisconsin at Madison has acknowledged altering a publicity photograph to add a black face to a crowd of white football fans, a step the college says it took to present an image of diversity.

The university said last week that it had digitally altered the cover of its fall admissions brochure to include a black senior, Diallo Shabazz, who says he has never even attended a football game at the university. The mistake was brought to light after a sharp-eyed staff member at the student newspaper, The Daily Cardinal, noticed that Mr. Shabazz’s face seemed to be lighted differently from the other students’.

(“You think anyone will notice we stuck a random black guy’s head in there?” “Nah… Print that thing!”)

 

Back then, it became such a viral thing (back before we really knew what viral was) that The Onion even took a shot at this stupidity:

DISCUSSION STARTER: What is your general feeling about using AI to alter reality, especially in a way like Stanford did? You could easily argue that people were being lazy, in that I’m sure they could have found a photo that represented the diversity mix the folks there wanted. You could also argue that this is deceptive, which calls into question every OTHER thing the folks present as fact. There are also a ton of other ways you can look at this, so have at it.

 

 

Six Important Things That Got Lost In The Story Of The SIU-Edwardsville Communication Director Who Filed A Police Report Against The Editor of The Student Newspaper

Student media and university officials tend to have relationships that range from somewhat cordial to downright vitriolic. This makes sense in a relatively adversarial system, in which the goal of the university is to present itself in the most positive light possible, while the goal of the student journalists is to present reality, regardless of how it makes the university look.

In the case of The Alestle at Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville, the relationship has devolved to the point in which a member of the school’s PR team filed a police report against the paper’s editor, claiming harassment via one line in an email. This is on top of a PR official saying her unfettered ability to sit in on interviews between student reporters and university personnel is “non-negotiable.” And those are just the most recent clashes over what is and isn’t acceptable under the First Amendment.

If you are behind on the story, there has been a TON of good reporting that can catch you up here:

The headlines of the story capture both the oddity and impact of this story: A clash over the First Amendment rights of student journalists ends up with an administrator essentially calling the cops on the editor, claiming harassment. What is getting overlooked however, reveals a bigger set of problems for the students, the university and even press freedom in general.

I exchanged a series of emails with The Aleste’s editor-in-chief, Dylan Hembrough and also conducted a phone interview with him, exchanged a series of emails with SIUE Director of Communications Nicole Franklin and did some deep dives into the background of this beef.

Rather than rehash what a lot of superior journalists have already reported, here are a few important things that are getting lost in the coverage of this story:

THIS ISN’T A ONE-TIME PROBLEM: A number of articles look at this moment as a singular incident, but it’s not. Although neither party could put a specific date on the start of the conflict, Hembrough, pointed to a story he wrote, regarding the university’s policy that resident assistants (RAs) were not allowed to talk to student media.

As the story made the rounds, the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) caught wind of it and eventually wrote a letter to SIUE, explaining how the university couldn’t clamp down on students’ free speech rights if they were to speak as individuals, not university representatives. In response, the university noted The Aleste’s story was inaccurate, but did not elaborate on why it was wrong or what clarifications they had provided to student workers about media interactions.

According to the FIRE website, the case remains active in the organization’s files.

Hembrough has been EIC for the past three years and said that he’s outlasted three head spokespeople, each of whom has been less than thrilled/cooperative when it comes to The Alestle, so clearly this isn’t a one-time problem.

 

THIS ISN’T AN ALESTLE-ONLY PROBLEM: FIRE keeps track of everything related to free-speech/expression and hasn’t found a lot great to say about SIUE. FIRE has labeled the institution as “red,” which means it has at least one policy that is exceptionally problematic in relation to free speech on campus. Here’s the general report card that outlines its ranking in free speech:

(To be fair to SIUE, UW-Madison is ranked 61 and still has a grade of D, even though it’s a bastion of liberalism that has the reputation of “Two’s company, three’s a protest.” Probably the more telling thing is SIUE’s ranking of 243 out of 261 colleges and universities. Private institutions like Notre Dame and Marquette University rank better and they’re technically ALLOWED to do more suppression than SIUE if they felt like it.)

In addition, the school settled a free-speech lawsuit in 2023 with former student Maggie DeJong, who argued the university violated her First Amendment rights. According to the suit, DeJong wore a “Back the Blue” hat to class as a way to show her support of police and counter speech related to “defunding the police.”

After several discussions with professors and administrators, a university official issued a no-contact order between DeJong and several classmates, an action the suit called viewpoint discrimination. In the settlement, the school paid DeJong $80,000 and agreed to revise policies related to issues like this in the future.

In 2018, College Republicans sued the school over a free-speech policy that literally restricted free speech to 0.0013% of the total campus footprint. Even worse, the policy regarding that tiny “Speech Zone” required that the university approve the “free speech” offered in that space at least two days in advance if the planned speech was expected to be fluffy and happy speech. If the speech could be more “controversial,” students needed to get the permission 90 days in advance.

What makes something “controversial” under that policy? That was at the sole discretion of the school. The school settled for $10K in legal fees and a promise to redo the policy.

Long story short, it’s not just a liberal thing or a student media thing. SIUE just seems like a place that treats free speech like it’s a cockroach problem that won’t go away.

 

WHO GETS TO CALL THEMSELVES JOURNALISTS?: The two key media reps for SIUE during this situation, Franklin and Executive Director Paula Bridges, have leaned heavily on their status as former journalists with decades of journalism experience while condemning The Alestle.

(EDITOR’S NOTE: Bridges has left her position at SIUE as of Sept. 16, according to an article on The Alestle website. Links to her staff pages at SIUE are now dead and she has not updated her LinkedIn profile with new career information as of this writing.)

Franklin made her bona fides known during an interview with the Edwardsville Intelligencer:

So as I navigated a career that straddled 30 years in television news and more than 25 as an indie filmmaker some would agree my work exemplifies a Black woman’s joy. I’ll take it. My desire to pursue communications in college in reference to broadcast media was what I saw as the only degree that made sense at the time.”

<SNIP>

“That’s an interesting question because I came to this role after working 30 years in news television as a video editor/engineer and more than 25 years as an independent filmmaker.

Bridges also calls herself a journalist on her LinkedIn page, noting experience in both print and broadcast. In the letter she wrote slamming The Alestle, she doubled down on that statement:

As a journalist with more than 30 years of experience with newspapers, news radio, magazines, and broadcast television, I will always defend First Amendment rights and freedom of the press. I also recognize the important obligation that accompanies the power to publish: verify facts before publication and correct errors when they occur.

I concluded my reporting career as an Emmy Award-winning news anchor, and served across various sectors including municipal government, public safety, the judiciary, and education. I am writing an open letter to our university community because I am deeply troubled by the direction and disposition of The Alestle as an exercise of journalism.

In digging into both of their backgrounds, it’s unclear to me how the math works and also how those experiences directly relate to any First Amendment support.

For Franklin, she lists the following items:

The big one, where she spent 17 years was a bit confusing, but in digging into her resume, it was a little clearer:

This was mostly production work, as opposed to news gathering or journalistic content creation. In addition the other two places where she worked that are categorized as “news” are basically morning programs where little in the way of hard-hitting news occurs. And again, I’d imagine she wasn’t responsible for the news reporting as a video editor.

In terms of Bridges, the experience brag is nowhere nearly commensurate with the resume she publicly shares. That “30 years” she opens her letter with really comes down to about eight or nine years of broadcast journalism at the anchor desk:

That’s actual experience in journalism, no doubt, even if it ended before a lot of The Alestle staffers were in grade school. Outside of that, however, her professional life has been on the PR side of the fence for numerous public institutions:

Add all that up and you more than double her time in journalism, not to mention it’s the most recent 17 years of her career, give or take. That’s not to criticize those jobs, as I teach students every day who want to take gigs like that, but I’d argue that those careers are more about reputation management and positive front-facing work as opposed to what news reporters do.

Also, given those positions, I’d wager a dollar to a doughnut that Hembrough and his crew have done more investigative, deep-dive, digging-around, according-to-Hoyle journalism stuff in the past three years than these two folks have done at any of their stops.

 

BELIEVE WHOMEVER YOU WANT, BUT CHECK THE RECEIPTS FIRST:  In most cases like this, one side puts out a list of issues it has about free speech or conflict and the other side goes silent. If you look back at the multi-part series we did here in Indiana University’s fight with the Indiana Daily Student, I tried to get comments from at least five people in administration and the only response I got was a set of links to previous statements that didn’t answer my questions.

In this situation, both Hembrough and Franklin have been active in presenting their cases to the media. As is the case with most mainstream media stories, space is limited and reporters want to play fair, so they grab a quote from each and move on.

In the case of Hembrough, the quotes mostly discuss the way in which the admin has been dumping all over the paper in public without having the facts right. In the case of Franklin, the quotes mostly present a case of the students making mistakes and not correcting them, all while arguing she’s totally in favor of free speech.

For example, Franklin made what appears to be a completely reasonable statement in an email to me:

This has never been about free speech or freedom of the press. SIUE has a long history of sponsoring The Alestle and training student journalists, and that commitment has not wavered.

The real issue is the lack of journalistic principles of objectivity, truthfulness, and accuracy. Calling for accuracy is not interference. The Alestle has repeatedly published information that is inaccurate and, despite requests for corrections, has been slow or unwilling to make them.

That comment sounds fair, in that being accurate and following journalistic principles should be at the core of what student media does. When I asked Hembrough about those allegations, he did more than comment.

He brought the receipts to prove stuff. 

In this timeline of links, rebuttals and clarifications, he names names, documents dates and shows his work. In picking through this over the last week, I could easily see how some of the comments Franklin had made in various comments were either inaccurate or in service of the university’s narrative.

He also had emails to support his statements that Franklin had been presented with information about her presence at interviews being a First Amendment violation, as well as her reactions, such as her statement that her presence was “non-negotiable.”

And as Hembrough said, “There are only so many ways you can slice the word non-negotiable.”

When it comes down to it, journalists are supposed to be objective, but we’re also supposed to be fans of reality. In other words, if one person says it’s raining and one person says it’s sunny, we aren’t supposed to just report both equally.

We’re supposed to look out the window and figure out who’s right, which is why checking those receipts is really important.

 

IT’S HARD TO SQUARE THE CIRCLE ON SIUE’S FIRST AMENDMENT TALK: What keeps coming up most in these discussions is the First Amendment and how it either is or isn’t being violated in this situation. In an email Franklin sent me, she noted:

Our position is straightforward: the University has a legitimate interest in ensuring that information it provides to the public is objective, truthful, accurate, and that factual errors concerning the University are identified and, where appropriate, corrected. That interest does not conflict with our commitment to free speech and free press.

Based on what I’ve seen of the coverage on this, the timeline Hembrough provided and my digging into the background on SIUE, the reporting is meeting those goals, with errors generally being corrected in what is a reasonable time period.

I’m uncertain as to how the university is parsing “truthful” versus “accurate” and it’s also interesting that the lack of objectivity seems to be focused on stories that don’t paint the university in the best light.

Setting those issues aside, experts in media law at multiple organizations have stated their concerns regarding the way in which the actions of SIUE’s PR folks are problematic in relation to the First Amendment rights of The Alestle staff. The response from the system’s lawyer doesn’t directly address the concerns.

If you’re really committed to the First Amendment, it means you have to support press freedom that is unfettered by governmental overreach, both direct and indirect. When experts in that field are telling you, point blank, you are in violation of the letter and spirit of that law, it might be time to reconsider your actions.

If sources are really concerned about accuracy, have them record the interview instead of having Franklin sit in. It’s a fair trade, in that both sides have a complete record of what happened and no governmental agent is there to potentially chill the exchange of information.

(SIDE NOTE: I emailed a couple people who have covered this story and a couple journalists who cover SIUE on the regular to ask one basic question: Does Franklin make a point of sitting in on your interviews as well? I’m trying to figure out if this is an Alestle-only thing or not. If anyone responds, I’ll add it here.)

Speaking of chilling, filing a police report against a student journalist feels an awful lot like a brush-back pitch. In our interview, Hembrough told me he got the email during class and his anxiety immediately kicked into overdrive:

I was pretty jarred. I’ll tell you that. So I got the email on Wednesday morning. I was in the middle of class, and I had to step out for about half an hour because I started to panic.

<SNIP>

I had been managing mentally pretty well up until that morning. I had to take some of my emergency medicine to avert the panic attack, which thankfully it kicked in just in time. But I still missed a decent chunk of class.

Actions like these don’t tend to send a message that someone is totally in favor of free speech. If you’re really and fully committed to the freedom of the press, you need to let it ride at all times, not just when you’re happy with what the press is doing.

 

SIUE IS BULLYING ITS OWN STUDENTS: In my interview with Hembrough, he was talking about the juxtaposition of the allegations that he harassed Franklin and the way in which the school has been treating The Alestle:

If that’s harassment, then what are they doing to us by sending a letter to every student and faculty and staff member on this campus, calling us liars and bad mouthing us to these national organizations?

Bullying their own students really is what it comes down to.

When we read stories about university administrators attacking student media, it’s often hard to remember that the student journalists actually CHOSE to be at the institutions that are attacking them. In many legal ways, they are like any other journalists who are gathering information and telling stories. However, they are also tuition-paying members of the larger university community.

Every university marketing campaign I’ve ever seen is filled with platitudes about how the school will be this fantastic place for its students, complete with career prep, academic inquiry and personal growth.

I’ve yet to see an asterisk on any of that marketing material that says, “Unless you are a student journalist who ticks us off, at which point, buckle your chinstrap.”

Good Good Golf runs Bad, Bad Ad: A look at the fallout from misogynistic advertising (A Throwback Post)

THE LEAD: Good Good Golf has seen a series of lost partnerships, lost jobs and lost credibility after an ad the company ran appeared to be promoting violence against women.

Good Good Golf faces mounting backlash for a controversial online video ad that sparked accusations of sexism.

On Thursday, the digital media company lost its three-year partnership with Callaway Golf, while the PGA Tour said Good Good would no longer sponsor one of the association’s tournaments in November. The ad, co-branded with Callaway, shows a male golfer shoving a female golfer to the ground as she reaches for his driver.

THE LEVEL OF STUPID GOES TO 11: What became interesting right after Callaway cut ties with Good Good was how tone deaf the CEO was in his social media posts:

The beleaguered CEO of Good Good just publicly blasted Callaway after the golf company ended its partnership with the YouTuber group over a controversial ad.

“Interesting that @CallawayGolf asks us to make an ad then approves it then asks us to take the fall then drops us in a coordinated media blitz and covers it up by giving a million dollars away thinking everyone will be ok with it,” Matt Kendrick wrote in a post on X.

Believe it or not, Kendrick “exited” the company shortly after the post and the rage against the ad failed to abate.

Speaking of soft language that didn’t tell us what really happened, Callaway’s apology from CEO Chip Brewer used some great passive-voice construction to stack sandbags regarding who was or wasn’t involved in OKing the ad:

“That approval should never have happened,” Brewer wrote. “Mistakes were made, and we are taking the matter very seriously.”

FROM THE “IS WE LEARNING YET?” DEPARTMENT: I have no idea what it takes to make a successful, well-received ad, but I do know that misogyny tends not to be a key component. All you have to do is look back at dozens of ads that failed for this specific reason. The one I tend to show in my ad class was this one from Dodge, which really went all out to make married life look appealing:

 

However, today’s throwback post takes a look at one of the most famous ads in this genre: The Peloton ad from hell, which inspired this segment on SNL’s “Weekend Update.”

 

God (and your husband) will be watching: The failed Peloton Christmas ad campaign

Unless you have been living in a cave, you probably know that Peloton has landed on the “most-hated” list for gifts this Christmas, thanks in large part to the ad shown above.

Social media users have skewered the ad for its gender stereotypes, its use of a “gender normative” set of characters and its generally creepy “God is watching” vibe:

Peloton is so far sticking by its widely mocked holiday ad. The spot, called “The Gift that Gives Back,” continued to air Tuesday evening on networks including ESPN, Lifetime, Bravo and HGTV, according to ad-tracking service iSpot, even as criticism grew.

The ad, about a woman whose husband gifts her an apparent life-changing exercise bike, sparked a gender backlash that clearly clashed with any seasonal cheer the brand was expecting.

“It’s a complete male fantasy ad,” says Kit Yarrow, a consumer psychologist, noting that the spot could inspire men to be “gifting heroes” and get “skinnier spouses.”

A Peloton costs between $2,250 and $2,700, depending on which package you buy. That’s pretty pricey for something destined to become a high-tech clothing rack. It’s probably even more expensive when you factor in the therapy you’ll need when the instructor starts screaming at you to work harder.

A good friend who is a feminist scholar nailed the Peloton ad in a way I couldn’t:

She is already fit and she documents every minute for him as if he is watching her every move. Look at her face. At the end she says her life is so much better but there is no evidence given why her life is better, except that she gets up before dawn when she doesn’t want to so she can ride some bike for him. No one should do such things only because another person wants them to.

After I read that post, I went back and rewatched the ad. I noticed things like the look on the wife’s face on day one: It’s a mix of fear and “I hope to please you.” The fact she records every day for the purpose of eventually showing him the video at the end is freakish. The fact that she seems to be biking at all hours seems obsessive.

The daughter seeing her already-thin mom biking like a maniac provides a strange modeling behavior. Also, what the hell was the guy doing all this time? Is he in a room full of TVs watching her like Billy Baldwin in “Sliver?”  At the local bar getting fat on beer and pork rinds, because, hey, it’s not like he has to worry about his waistline.

Holiday ads for high priced items tend to really lead to awkward advertisements. The Kay Jewelers “Woman who is scared of lightning and needs man to protect her” ad stereotypes women in multiple ways. Also their slogan of “Every Kiss begins with Kay” seems to imply, “Wanna get laid? Buy her some jewelry!”

Pick any Lexus ad that involves a big red bow and you essentially can see even more awkwardness. If you want to step past the fact it’s pretty much always some rich handsome dude buying some trophy wife woman an overpriced Toyota with better hubcaps, you can still see some real creepy in this ad:

Not sure what they were going for here. “Lexus: Bring out the little girl in your wife.” Eeew.

If the maxim, “There’s no such thing as bad publicity” is true, Peloton is getting a heck of a lot of value out of body-shaming a stick-thin woman. People are debating the ad online and morning shows are running it on a constant loop to give it an official “tsk tsk.”

However, the truth probably is that the company did more harm than good to its brand. The stock price, which got a quick uptick after the ad went viral, has since gone back down, in a slide some are calling a “nightmare.” Also, any guy who picked up a Peloton in November thinking, “She was asking about this thing. I’m a great guy for getting it.” is now swearing up and down to Citibank that this was a fraudulent charge.

Maybe the only person who came out of this with any benefit was Monica Ruiz, the wife in the commercial, who scored another gig based on her role:

The Cleveland Plain Dealer’s AI department co-opted a staffer’s byline for a story. Head Honcho Chris Quinn still thinks AI is our salvation.

Actual footage of what happened at The Cleveland Plain Dealer’s AI desk this week… 

THE LEAD: The Cleveland Plain Dealer has apparently engineered a new form of AI that not only creates crappy content, but also finds a way to place the blame on an uninvolved human reporter:

A journalist has accused Cleveland.com — the online home of The Plain Dealer, Ohio’s largest newspaper — of publishing an article under her byline without her consent, knowledge, or approval. The article was generated by the “Cleveland.com Express Desk,” which “uses AI tools to assist in producing content” that the newspaper claims is “reviewed and edited by staff.”

The supposed writer, Kaitlin Durbin, was not thrilled about having her employer slap her byline on whatever the hell Cleveland.com’s robot overlords had decided to create:

The paper didn’t pull the rather banal article, but instead pulled Durbin’s byline which was like saying, “Hey, remember how we said AI wasn’t going to hurt the newsroom? Well… Um… Look! It’s a picture of a guy in a suit made of Bluey’s hide!”

(SIDE NOTE, PART I: This story could have used some actual reporting, as this literally reads like a press release that was copied and pasted into the paper. Also, anytime someone says they are quitting  a job for “personal reasons,” I tend to believe that there’s something less benign happening that is just SCREAMING for someone to dig into it. )

DYNAMICS OF WRITING FLASHBACK: This whole thing would not be half as delicious as it is, if it weren’t for Plain Dealer Head Honcho Chris Quinn’s sermons from the Mount about AI being all that and a bag of chips.

You might remember we covered this back in February, where Quinn was so “Team AI,” you would have thought it were a “Twilight” character competing for Bella Swan’s affections. He also was nice enough to tell all of us in education that we were old, stubborn cusses who refused to see how great AI is and how much we are harming our students.

Well, at least when our kids turn in their papers, they actually have their own names on them…

(SIDE NOTE PART II: The clip I desperately want to use here to express my feelings about this whole situation comes from the opening of “Another 48 Hours,” when Nick Nolte is questioned by internal affairs after he shoots a guy and accidentally blows up a race track. The people at Sage would have a full on aneurysm if I posted it, so instead, I’m linking to this clip, while also telling you that it’s number nine on the top 10 quotes. Watch at your discretion.)

IT’S “ONE TO GROW ON” TIME: As much as I doubt Chris Quinn will read this, I still think it’s worth the rest of us to dig in and learn something from this situation. Here are the best  “One To Grow On” moments I can pull out of this:

You can’t let automation make you lazy: One of the biggest risks of automation is that the humans supposedly overseeing it tend to pay less attention to the details. When we had to look up every word instead of relying on spellcheck, we tended to edit more carefully and thus avoid headlines that proclaimed the opening of a “pubic library” or one like this:

Generative AI moves that risk even higher, because a) it’s capable of doing more complex stuff for us than traditional AI, b) We’re not as familiar with its risks and c) We don’t know how best to backstop it yet.

This means we need to be MORE diligent with this stuff, not less.

 

What is the true Cost vs. Value of AI?: In his magnum opus, singing the praises of AI, Quinn explained how reporters will benefit from all the time AI could save them, so they could do other more important things. (Apparently, in this case, it saved the reporter enough time to go on a honeymoon without actually having to file the story she supposedly wrote…)

He also opined on how the readers will benefit from better overall coverage and how the world will benefit because people are now part of an “energized electorate” that will engage like never before.

The idea of saving time, energy and resources sounds great in terms of value, but what about the cost associated with ticking off a reporter who is publicly wondering aloud if the paper thinks it owns her soul?

Some portion of your newsroom probably thinks you’re already selling them out for a sack of magic beans and the promise of fourth-quarter profits for the hedge funds that own the place. Now, I imagine they’re less likely to believe that “AI is your friend” and more likely to think “The T-800 is coming for your job and your soul…”

Also, what about the cost associated with the loss of readership confidence in ALL of your work now? Before, it might have been, “OK, don’t trust anything with that AI Buzzword byline on it, but we know Kaitlyn and she’s solid.” Now it’s “OK, did the person we thought wrote the story actually write the story, or was it even a person at all?”

Trust and credibility have always been built a grain at a time when it comes to the media’s relationship with the public, and it’s always been destroyed in an instant when someone makes a short-sighted decision to cut corners.

AI can do a lot, but it can’t change that.

 

You’re a journalist, not a cult leader: One of the biggest problems here was Quinn’s “nothing to see here” response when the byline situation broke:

After this story was published, Quinn told Futurism that the byline blunder was “a simple mistake, the result of a miscommunication between a couple of editors.”

“It was corrected as soon as we learned of it from the Tweet,” Quinn continued, adding that he’s “written extensively about our policies, practices and controls regarding AI content in my From the Editor columns this year” and directing us to a post containing links to his statements on Cleveland.com’s AI policies. “If you’re looking for information about us, it’s all there,” said Quinn. “I have nothing to add.”

Back when he first was telling everyone who would listen that AI was not going to be a problem, he was singing this tune:

Because we want reporters gathering information, these jobs are 100 percent reporting. We have an AI rewrite specialist who turns their material into drafts. We fact-check everything. Editors review it. Reporters get the final say. Humans — not AI — control every step.

If that’s true, where did this story come from? Clearly the reporter given the initial credit (Durbin) didn’t write it, and apparently neither did anyone else, as there’s no byline on it now. Also, way to throw those human editors under the bus, just to make sure no one was thinking about the AI’s role in this screw-up.

Guys like this remind me of the line, “Often wrong, never in doubt,” and as bad as that normally is, it’s really disturbing to see it from the editor of a major media outlet.

Journalists are supposed to play the skeptic, hedge their bets, play with caution and find balance. It keeps us out of trouble and allows us to see things as they are, not as we would like them to be. It also allows us to fess up when we’re wrong, something that (oddly enough) inspires confidence in the people we serve.

If Chris Quinn wants to talk up the positives and crap all over people who point out the negatives, that’s fine, but do it as a PR guy for an AI firm or as the prophet for some sort of futuristic tech cult.

Journalists don’t have the luxury of arrogant presumption.

Hypocrisy, Thy Name is “Insider:” A Deeper Look at The Athletic’s Postmortem on The Dianna Russini/Mike Vrabel Scandal

THE LEAD: From the “Oh, really? Ya THINK?!?” Department…

An internal investigation by The Athletic found that the relationship between Dianna Russini, its former senior N.F.L. reporter, and Mike Vrabel, the head coach of the New England Patriots, was a “clear violation” of the company’s standards.

In a report released Thursday detailing findings of its monthslong investigation, The Athletic said that the relationship gave the appearance of a conflict of interest and Ms. Russini should have revealed it to the company.

CATCHING UP: As I think everyone short of the Beaver County Tidbit has reported earlier this year, Russini and Vrabel had photos of them published that made it clear there was more than a “source/reporter” relationship going on.

Russini first vigorously defended herself against these allegations, saying everything was taken out of context and she wasn’t going to dignify this non-story with a response.

Dianna Russini’s PR team making it clear that there’s nothing to this story….

Meanwhile, Vrabel made a vague mea culpa, complete with his decision to attend counseling because… um… you got me on this one.

RANDOM SIDE NOTE: Can I have her job? According to a story written after the relationship became public, Russini was making bank:

Ms. Russini was not just any reporter. The Athletic paid her an annual salary of close to $800,000, according to a former manager who had knowledge of her salary negotiation. This would have made her one of the highest-paid journalists at the Times Company.

She apparently filed somewhere north of 900 stories during her three years at the publication, along with appearing on podcasts, doing videos and more, so I’m not saying she didn’t work at her job, but damn… At what my kids are telling me they’re making coming out of college, we could staff a decent-sized newsroom out here for what The Athletic was paying the self-described “straight-up MILF.”

HYPOCRISY, THY NAME IS INSIDER: First things first for the journalism kids out there: Don’t have any kind of snuggly relationships of any kind with any source if you are a reporter.

If you somehow managed to find yourself with a potentially risky situation (as I once did in getting engaged to a city council rep, even though I didn’t cover city council as my beat), disclose the relationship ASAP and then figure out if the juice is worth the squeeze depending on the rules of your gig and the level of interest you have in your significant other.

But here’s the one question nobody seems OK with asking at any of these major media outlets:

Was the Vrabel situation worse than anything else “insiders” are doing?

I get that Americans are always going to clutch their pearls when sex-like-stuff becomes public and I know that women (particularly women covering sports) are constantly treated less favorably than men.

But let’s not pretend sports “insiders” are anything more than glorified PR agents that get paid way too much and get away with way more than they should.

In the same timeline in which the Russini-Vrabel was being feverishly dissected by journalists, fellow “insider” Jay Glazer was pouring back the suds with coaches at a pool party he has apparently hosted for the past 18 years.

The reporters tsk-tsking Russini used footage of this party to show that Vrabel wasn’t present, apparently because he was out “running the offense” with Russini or something. Apparently, it was fine for Glazer to set up a day-drinking session with the people he covers, and no one has tried to put a stop to an event older than the incoming college freshman.

Glazer has gotten in deep with all sorts of players and teams, including serving as an MMA trainer for several players. He also once got away with this:

I often recall Walter Cronkite demanding that LBJ let him sign a bill… 

As we noted when Adam Schefter wasn’t behaving like a paragon of journalistic virtue, the “insider” culture that has consumed sports journalism is overflowing with hypocrisy and self-promotion.

The “insiders” pretend to be journalists when they want to break stories, but pretend not to be when they want to break journalistic rules. Charissa Thompson tried to play this angle a few years back, when she said she “made up” quotes as a sideline reporter, only to try to walk it back.

Even without the whole “Oh my stars! She might have touched his manly virtue!” stuff, Russini seemed a bit ethically compromised by the spoils of stardom. She apparently bragged about hanging out with the who’s who of the NFL, and even trying to use a coach to get her out of a speeding ticket.

Other sports reporters, whose livelihoods depend on scoops and staying ahead of the pack, see what the “insiders” do and how well they are treated, so they figure if that’s the game, let’s go play it.

This is why we get more and more “anonymous sources” for less and less important content. It’s why we see more grandstanding and brand building from the “big names” in the media instead of following the same rules  everyone else has to.  It’s why we see people pushing the edge of the envelope in what is acceptable to cover and how much of a jagwad they feel comfortable being in covering it.

It’s also why when sports and news meet, sometimes some a reporter will take a corner or two too quickly and end up getting sued back to the Stone Age.

Professional sports loves themselves some PR, and basically, that’s what they get when they pick out their favorite mouthpieces and spoon feed them content they want to have in the public.

So, let’s stop pretending that Glazer, Schefter and dozens of other “reporters” who start every sentence with “The general manager told me exclusively that…” haven’t sold their journalistic souls for heavy bank and easier scoops.

They might not be pulling tongue with a coach in a hot tub, but they’re no less ethically compromised than someone in a romantic relationship with a source.

What People Who Love Your Video Podcast Content Hate About Your Video Podcasts (Part II)

If you watch one or two episodes of this, you get the distinct feeling that literally everyone in the 1970s was on drugs… 

(ED NOTE: Last week, we took a look at the things that made fans of a podcast topic stop watching video podcasts. In that segment, we tended to look at content and approach, so in this segment we’ll be looking at the smaller details that can drive the viewers crazy. Hope these help.)

Just for a brief recap: as part of the annual The Mid Year Freakout Book Tag, a number of vloggers and book influencers took to YouTube to present their views on the books they’ve read, what they want to read and how close they are to their annual reading goal. As Amy watched these, I asked her to keep track of the things that made her stop watching any particular video and we would chat about it later. The idea was that she loved the content, but still wasn’t going to dedicate her time to something that didn’t pass muster for her.

Here are some of the more “detail oriented” elements she noted:

SENSORY OVERLOAD: Apparently, some of these content creators didn’t get the memo that “less is more” when it comes to stuff like this. Amy noted that the most annoying ones would be weaving in pointless visuals, using weird filters or doing edits that drew attention to the edits. While she was trying to learn about a book, she found herself fending off the feeling that she was going to have a seizure from all the blinking and cutting going on.

This is a relatively common phenomenon when people get ahold of some newer form of technology. When word-processing programs took over from standard typewriters, people were using all sorts of weird fonts for no real reason. When HTML coding became accessible to folks, I remember all sorts of colored fonts and even the dreaded “blink” tag, which made it almost impossible to read.

Editing programs give us more options than the simple “cut,” such as wipes, crumpled paper cuts and even the weird raindrop thing. People think they’re being edgy or innovative when they use them, but they never once think about how damned difficult they’re making it for the audience.

If the content is good and the presentation is strong, you don’t need to jack up the production with all sorts of weird stuff and visual stunts. It’s the reason why “Citizen Kane” doesn’t have any car chases or explosions, while every “Fast and Furious” movie has about a million.

 

PRACTICE, PRACTICE, PRACTICE: Someone once told me that great acting is done in way where it doesn’t look like acting at all. That’s probably why I sucked at it, given I could memorize all the lines, but I delivered them like I was a scared kid at a spelling bee. Great actors practice over and over and over again until what they’re doing looks and sounds conversational, but is really a well-learned presentation.

Amy got peeved a few times when it was clear someone was trying to spitball their way through content without really having spent any time practicing what they were going to say or do. This included weird pauses in the content because they forgot what book would be discussed next, or stops in the middle of a sentence because they forgot what they were going to say. It also got weird when the podcaster wanted to show off a book, but couldn’t find the right book and we were all there just hanging out, waiting for the person to find it. (Editing doesn’t hurt here, either…)

Practicing will help eliminate some terrible verbal mannerisms. The “ums” and “likes” and “y’knows” will crop up less frequently, but you can also look for other things you do that might annoy the heck out of your audience. In one case, a video presenter kept saying “No one can believe it” about EVERYTHING to the point where Amy said, “I can’t believe I watched this for this long” and flipped away from it. I have no idea if the content was worth anything, but it wasn’t worth enough to hear “No one can believe it” one more time, apparently.

Spend the time working your way through the material before you put it on video. Practicing, like when you had to give a speech for class or do a presentation in front of important people, will limit the nerves, smooth out the rough spots and get you ready for a clear, coherent and confident chunk of content.

 

AVOID DISTRACTIONS: I’ve had conversations with people where I get distracted by something weird going on with them, and suddenly, I’m fixating on whatever that distraction. George Carlin once did a bit about someone laughing through their nose and blowing a snot on their shirt. That actually happened in a conversation I was having and all I kept thinking was, “There’s this giant snot on their shirt…” They could have been getting ready to stab me to death or tell me the cure for cancer, but all I’m thinking is, “That snot is going to dry there…”

Amy mentioned a number of weird distractions that bothered her. In one case it was some freakish piece of pottery on a shelf behind the person. In another case it was the lip gloss the person was wearing that was so shiny, it was almost creating star bursts on the video. Whatever it was, she suddenly got sucked into this moment of weird and eventually couldn’t hang in there for the content.

It’s hard to come up with exactly the right amount of background elements. Too much stuff and it’s “Squirrel Theater.” Not enough stuff and it looks like you’re filming a hostage video in a shipping container. This is where both practice and “beta testing” can go a long way. Put something together, have people you trust give it a look and see if there’s anything they would recommend you get rid of or add.

Hope these help. See you next week.